Path:Faramir is found by Theodred and whomever else he conscripts into helping him.

1. Chapter 1: A Stranger in the Woods
2. Faramir says: "Excellent idea, Mablung. I'll head the mission myself!"
3. Faramir has no choice but to call off his men before they are killed. He is captured by the attacker
4. It's an Elf!
5. The elf is from Rivendell – twins or Glorfindel or Erestor or Elrond – you decide
6. They meet with Elladan, Elrohir and the Rohirrim envoy (I vote for Theodred)
7. It’s Theodred
8. FLASHBACK Faramir is indeed no virgin. He recalls the (sordid) incestuous sex he experienced at a very young age.
9. Theodred goes after him to try and help
10. Faramir is found by Theodred and whomever else he conscripts into helping him.